Latest articles  
 

 

 

 
The Pre-Requisites of a Mujtahid

A’bdullah ibn A’mr reported that nabi (saw) said “Verily, Allah will not destroy knowledge by snatching it away from his slaves but he will destroy knowledge by taking away the lives of the u’lemah until there will not even remain a single a’lim, people will then take the illiterate as leaders. They will be questioned and they will give fataawa without knowledge. They will go astray and will lead others astray.” (BUKHAARI, MUSLIM)

Linguistically, ijtihad is from ‘jahada’ [to strive] and it means in juristic terminology, to exhaust effort to reach the truth of a particular matter of fiqh. Note that ijtihad is by its nature open to error and is not to be performed where there is a clear shari’ah ruling on a matter from a plain text of the Quran or Sunnah. Ijtihad is needed to extract the rule of Allah (swt) for a new situation when there is no explicit text or the situation is not totally clear as to what textual rules it would apply to.

There are various grades of mujtahid e.g.

• Mujtahid Mutlaq [unrestricted in his ijtihad due to him having established his own usoolul fiqh with regards to general evidences and universal principles],

• Mujtahid Masala [competent to make ijtihad in a specific issue or group of issues]

• Mujtahid Madh-hab [competent to make ijtihad based upon the usoolul fiqh of a complete mujtahid]

• Mujtahid Murajih [competent to outweigh between the different ijtihad within a school, in later times this has also been applied to scholars outweighing between different opinions from different schools, however, that obviously contains the bias of the mujtahid murajihs own legal thought]

• Mujtahid Mustakhrij [competent to trace and authenticate the ijtihad within a madh-hab and distinguish between the preferred views]

• There are also other grades of mujtahid which have been mentioned by the usooleeyeen and some have given them different names with similar meanings.

From the basic requirements of a mujtahid there are the following [NOTE: The requirements for ijtihad differ from madh-hab to madh-hab and on the type of ijtihaad tha is being performed, also circumstances are also relevant, there may be times when the most knowledgeable of a community does not possess every tool of ijtihad that would ideally be required but he still uses all of his knowledge, resources and abilities to spend effort on reaching the best decision he can.]:-

1 Muslim
Allah (swt) says ““Verily, We have sent down to you the Book as a clarification for all matters, a guidance, a mercy and good news for the Muslims” (an Nahl 16:89)

2 Sane
Nabi (saw) was reported by A’li to have said “The pen is lifted for three – one who sleeps till he awakes, a child till he becomes mature and an insane person till he gains his sanity” (ABU DAWOOD kitabul Hudood, AHMAD, NASAA’I, IBN MAAJAH and graded ‘saheeh’ according to AL HAAKIM as reported by IBN HAJR AL ASQALAANI in ‘Bulooghul Maraam min Adillatul Ahkaam’ [kitaabun Nikaah no.927])

3 Intelligent
“…Thus do We explain the signs in detail for a people who use their intellects (ya’qiloon)” (ar Room 30:28)

4 Arabic Language
“Verily, We have sent it down as an Arabic Quran in order that you may understand.” (Yusuf 12:2) This includes:-

i) Ilmul Lughah
ii) I’lmul Laghwah (dialects)
iii) I’lmun Nahw
iv) I’lmus Sarf
v) a) A’mm/Khass b) Mantooq/Mafhoom c) Muhkam/Mutashabbih

5 U’loomul Quran
This includes:-

i) Asbaabun Nuzool
ii) Ayaatul Ahkaam
iii) Makki/Madani
iv) Seven Readings
v) An Naasikh wal Mansookh

6 U’loomul Hadeeth
This includes:-

i) Asbaabun Nuzool
ii) Ahadeethul Ahkaam
iii) An Naasikh wal Mansookh Abu A’la ibn ash Shikhir reports The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) abrogated some of his commands by others, just as the Qur'an abrogates some part with the others. (MUSLIM [no.675])
iv) Daa’eef/Hasan/Saheeh
v) Mawqoof/Marfu’/Musnad
vi) I’lmur Rijaal
vii) I’mud Diraayah

7 I’lmul Ijtihaad wal Taqleed

8 Al Adillatul Ijmaliyyah (The general evidences) Al Qawaa’id ul Kulliyyah or Qawaa’id ul Usoolul Fiqh (The general principles relating to deduction of laws)

9 Fataawatul U’lemaa’ and Fiqhul Madhaahib (The rulings of the previous scholars and schools of law) [for mujtahid murrajih]